Jared Kushner says he and Steve Witkoff spoke with Putin aide Yuri Ushakov, then consulted Ukraine and European partners about a peace deal. On the same day, Ushakov rejected European participation in the next planned meeting. Moscow and Washington are describing different talks.
The Calls
The November 16 morning call covered progress and next steps. The European group included national security advisers from Germany, France, Britain, Poland and Italy, and representatives of the EU and NATO.
Kushner wants direct Europe-Russia dialogue. He says the US is preparing the agenda for a multilateral meeting soon. Ushakov’s account cuts straight across that plan. He said EU involvement was premature; the meeting was being prepared for the US, Ukraine and Russia alone.
The Security Terms
Kushner says NATO will remain the central pillar of European security. He describes a durable settlement built on existing European institutions, stronger security commitments, better communication, transparency and ways to reduce the risk of escalation.
Russia’s November 10 non-paper demands something else. NATO forces and bases pulled back to the alliance’s 1997 boundaries, away from its eastern flank. Moscow also wants a wholesale rewrite of Europe's security arrangements around spheres of influence, an end to the French and British nuclear umbrella, and a ban on Western weapons for Ukraine. The fight is over whether eastern NATO members keep the security arrangements they have now.
What Kushner Calls Progress
Kushner says a successful deal would leave Ukraine sovereign, secure and prosperous, free to choose its future. He points to work with Ukraine and Europe on three elements:
- credible guarantees against another Russian attack
- a route to EU membership
- a postwar recovery plan covering rebuilding, investment and growth
He acknowledges that both Ukraine and Russia must accept a final agreement. But he says private discussions are producing constructive ideas that narrow their differences.
Those ambitions need a favourable account of closed-door talks to succeed.
Kushner still wants Europe at the next table. Moscow’s written demands attack the NATO role Kushner says will endure. The underlying positions remain incompatible even if you call it progress.